Strategy #2: Calculated Defiance: How to Play by the Small Rules So You Can Break the Big Ones
Don't Leap Without a Parachute: Why Strategic Conformity Wins the Side Hustle Game
In the last newsletter, I announced that I am writing Book #2: a non-fiction book about the twelve marketing strategies I discovered while researching my biographical novel, Saving Vincent: A Novel of Jo van Gogh. You can read Strategy #1 from the last issue here.
Are you more of an “ask for forgiveness” rule-breaker?
Or more of a “get permission first” rule-abiding kind of person?
“It depends,” you might respond.
Exactly.
When we think of entrepreneurs who change the world, we often picture the lone wolf—a reckless rebel running wild outside the pack, completely detached from society, howling at the moon, and burning down the status quo. But lasting brilliance doesn't require you to starve in the wilderness.
That’s the essence of Calculated Defiance, the second entrepreneurial strategy I gleaned from studying Jo van Gogh’s work in building a world-class legacy for Vincent van Gogh after his death. It’s the art of playing by the small rules so you have the room to break the big ones.
It’s not about being a rogue outsider for the sake of it; it's about strategically choosing your own territory.
Jo van Gogh’s Quiet Rebel Era
For a heartbroken Jo, this pivotal moment came while in the depths of grief at her husband’s passing in 1891. Suddenly widowed at the age of 28 with a 1-year-old baby. In Paris—far from her childhood Dutch home—with no income, it was a foregone conclusion that she would return to her father’s house in Amsterdam.
Instead, she took a 180-degree turn. She refused her father’s instructions; and chose to move back to the Netherlands to open a boarding house, a socially acceptable occupation for a widow at that time.
Choosing her own roof over her father’s roof was the first of many selective rules Jo would break. This is the heart of Calculated Defiance: it isn't about being reckless, but rather choosing precisely which rules to follow and which to bend.
She stayed within the “acceptable” lane of running a boarding house to secure a steady cash flow and a home for her son—a disobedient choice wrapped in just enough propriety to keep her critics at arm’s length.
It’s here that she also had her inheritance of paintings and drawings shipped and stored in the attic of her boarding house. Keeping the collection together was her first smart move, but it also attracted the first of many attacks. Her family and husband’s friends gave her intense pressure to either liquidate it or hand it over.
But because she had secured her independence (and Dutch law protected her property rights as a widow), she owned the assets completely. When the art world ultimately realized the value of the collection, they would have to come to her. She held all the cards.
For today’s entrepreneur, the idea of calculated, selective defiance of the status quo destroys the myth that you have to leap off a cliff without a parachute. It shows that securing your baseline—whether that’s keeping a day job while building a side hustle, or offering a standard, predictable service to fund your truly innovative project—can be a smart way to protect your long-term vision.
Case Study: How Brownie Wise Built a Living Room Empire
Here’s an example of another entrepreneur who demonstrated the mindset of Calculated Defiance.
In the 1950s, women were heavily restricted by post-war domestic expectations. The pioneering businesswoman Brownie Wise used those exact restrictions as her staging ground.
The Safety of Convention: Wise operated entirely within the acceptable social boundary of the 1950s: suburban housewives hosting living-room gatherings. To the outside world, it looked like harmless neighborhood socializing.
The Strategic Defiance: Tupperware was failing on hardware store shelves because people didn’t understand how the airtight seal worked. Wise defied the entire traditional retail distribution model. She pulled the product out of stores and engineered the “Tupperware Party,” doing in-home demonstrations of the product. She built a massive, independent, matriarchal sales network that has since given millions of women and men their own income and autonomy.
The Leverage: Wise made Tupperware so wildly successful that the company’s founder, Earl Tupper, named her Vice President of Marketing in which she ran the entire marketing empire. She took a plastic bowl and turned it into a cultural and financial phenomenon from a living room couch. Ultimately, her home party model inspired hundreds of others and serves the basis for the “side hustle” direct sales businesses that exist today.
Notice how the lesson from both Jo van Gogh and Brownie Wise isn’t simply to “go off and be independent.” Instead, Calculated Defiance uses the safety of convention to fund the risk of autonomy.
Strategy #2:
Defiance buys your independence. Strategy turns it into leverage.
Jo showed you don’t have to be a reckless rebel to change the world. Independence didn’t draw the crowd—but it gave her the absolute authority to execute the brilliant marketing strategies that did.
Next up are her first strategies toward getting started, or market penetration, but in the meantime. . .
Ready to break a rule?
I am!
Comments